The Diary of Jane

topic posted Tue, February 5, 2008 - 3:59 PM by  Broke Ben (A...
I recently wrote this as a response to someone who commented on the fact that the message of my last blog post was a bit depressing. I started to explain, then once I'd written it out realized how utterly crushed I really was. I find this surprising, as I'm kind of famous for being uncrushable.

I've created an anonymous account, something I rarely do, for obvious reasons and to protect the people involved, who's names are also changed. Maybe I just need another perspective from a faceless person that knows the whole story, maybe I need a reality check or maybe just a hug. Either way I had to let it out. I had to.

The fact is, I'm in love with my best friend. I have been for a long time, almost since we met. I was with someone already. In fact, the way we met was Jane trying to hook up with her. Jane was with someone too, and I became best friends with both of them.

What I felt in those days has lingered, because at the time without putting too fine a point on it I had had a pretty rough run of significant others in my life who enjoyed leaving bruises n' not in the fun way. I know it's very rare in men, but it happens, and it happened to me a couple of times in a row. Point is, Jane took me in, cared for the parts of me that were broken when I got the courage to get out of a particularly long-running travesty of a relationship. After, I was barely there.

They built me up, they even gave me a place to live, and more through what I saw between them (though the relationship was ultimately doomed) I re-learned about love and the way people who love each other treat each other.

I came to admire my best friend, and as I said I came to be in love with her. Still, I had learned the skills I needed to make it a pure love, one that didn't threaten I'd do something to sabotage her relationship or even cause me to covet her overlymuch. That feeling gave me the faith to face everything that came after, to get to here. That feeling even made me a "True" friend for what felt to me like the first time in my life.

That, give or take, is the back-story. Since, she moved to California and I moved back to my home state for a year and a half. When Amber (my now wife) and I moved here we got together, her newly single and me in the first *Real* relationship in my life.

Long story short we went out, ended up in a limo plied with WAAAAY too much vodka and then back at her place. A threesome ensued. While due to the sheer amount we had drank it was by no means my finest work, but I always held it as a singular moment, important. Me able to express my love in the only way I hadn't been able to, and with the two people I cared most about in the world. I had no illusions, I took it for what it was. If I seem to harbor a longing for the memory it's only because the memory itself to me is so sweet.

Even when we'd first started spending time together, it didn't take me long to realize while Jane and I created a fantastic gear, at the heart of it she comes from a much brighter place than I do. I could never dwell there, my eyes could never adjust. It was something I excepted with a sweet and excruciating sting, crossed myself and gave thanks for all that I did have in this life, and moved forward. As I'm fond of saying, I always knew Jane would never feel as much for me as I did for her.

But today I got a letter from her, it was titled "confession" and it was pretty much a denunciation and apology for her part in the act, and a very detailed account of exactly why it meant absolutely nothing to her, and in fact *could* not have at that time in her life.

I guess I'm upset, sad and frustrated. She wrote me this because I don't hide my appreciation for her. I mean, she's my best friend. But, due to the particularly artsy and editorially inclined sort of people that we are evidentally my appreciation has become so overt that my friend, my junior of SEVERAL years, felt the need to "check" me.

This is profound, what I feel. It's profound and wonderful and doesn't require a damn thing from anyone. I love who Jane is, and for all the subtleties surrounding that the simple fact of it was the foundation for alot of who I am today.

And I'm struck by the fact that no one does understand. Or worse, that they do and don't want it.

suddenly, I find myself out of words.
posted by:
Broke Ben (Angel's Alt)
California
  • Our Brightness

    Wed, February 6, 2008 - 9:40 AM

    rejection is always painful.
    it sounds like Jane, who you describe as - "my junior of SEVERAL years", wasn't as tactful as she could have been.
    and it sounds as though you have some pain and bitterness about that.
    but, maybe try and rephrase her statements to you - look at the deeper meaning behind the words.

    I don't know what age Jane is... but - we are all trying to find our way.
    You have put certain expectations around Jane - saying she is somehow "lighter - brighter" than you, and that speaks to your own self-awareness & esteem.
    but Ben... stop being Broke!
    trying to be playful here... just look at the name you chose as nom de plume.

    you are not broken.
    you have at least as much brightness and lightness as Jan does - if not more.
    maybe, you are just better at hiding it.

    the story you describe shows a genuine selflessness - or at least an attempt at that.
    With the humility to know you can grow.

    to some extent you may be here and posting this in an attempt have people bash Jane so you can defend her...
    to prove your love?

    but again we are all trying to find our way...
    one of the great dichotomies of people (not hypocrisies) is that sometimes they see and try to project things about themselves that they fear is not true.
    Brightness and lightness unfortunately is one of the most challenging.

    But the paradox is many claim to be afraid of their darkness... building big walls and barriers to protect ourselves and others form our darkness - but it is our light that we are most afraid to expose.
    the glory and wonder of our real genuine selves and the splendor that resides there.

    so we don our darkness as a cloak or we don the clothes and garb of "enlightened" - all the while avoiding the path that we know will lead us to where we can self-actualize - where we can be our brightest.

    so while you are hurt...
    and it is ok to feel that - you need to allow yourself to feel it AND to let it go
    you just need to let it go... all of it... let it be and try to surround yourself with the lightness and brightness of self-love and acceptance.
    and accept how Jane is.

    And be thankful for the opportunity to grow.
    be thankful to Jane for showing you a way to grow.
    be thankful to yourself for being wise, bright and wonderful enough to seize this opportunity to grow.
    • Re: Our Brightness

      Wed, February 6, 2008 - 11:20 AM
      I will say this. I am offended, hurt, but not bitter. I would defend "Jane" insomuch as if someone were to tell me this made her a bad person I wouldn't agree, but I always knew that there were parts of her life for some strange reason she never trusted me with, never showed me. Things like this force me to face that fact.

      No, I don't mourne the Love that could have been, because it couldn't have been.

      I mourne the friendship that's in jeapordy because she waited a YEAR to tell me all of this. I feel blindsided, punch-drunk.

      That, and a two page letter consisting almost an entirely of an explanation why a girl you slept with had absolutely not the slightest interest in you at all is something that you throw back a couple of beers and talk to your best friend ABOUT.

      The worst? That this entire situation leaves me with no one to talk to, or confide in, but strangers.

      (no offense, typing this out is the closest I can get to catharsis, and without you that wouldn't be possible)
      • Re: Our Brightness

        Wed, February 6, 2008 - 12:01 PM
        > I will say this. I am offended, hurt, but not bitter. <
        > ...she waited a YEAR to tell me all of this <
        > ...and a two page letter consisting almost an entirely of an explanation... <
        > ...this entire situation leaves me with no one to talk to, or confide in... <


        just to offer...
        you might be angrier than you realize.

        honestly... the more you reveal... the more it seems she isn't as aware (or as bright) as you think she is.
        she may be just as confused and fumbling through life as everyone else...
        and therefore, maybe we can allow them their flaws - even when they cause us a great deal of pain.

        • Re: Our Brightness

          Fri, February 8, 2008 - 9:43 AM
          eh' the girl's pretty quick on the draw, if anything I think its a matter of being too close to the situation, not giving me enough credit...

          Basically it's like this, I say that first she fixed me. Perhaps you are not aware of just how visceral and messy that process was. I was a battered boyfriend, basically the most pathetic lump of human I've ever been, and her and another friend, who ended up wasting the rest of our friendship on a disagreement over a *living situation* (a completely different story) Knit me back together. Maybe it didn't require alot of effort, maybe all they had to do was be present and my will to reach out did the rest, but it couldn't have been easy to watch.

          In the end, and what sucks quite a bit, is here I am. Powerful, expressive, confident, in love. I can carry not only my weight but the weight of several of those around me if they so choose to ask.

          If what she sees after FIVE YEARS is that boy she took in with the "broken wing syndrome" that she had to coddle and let act and talk like a fool for a year rather than break this matchstick Ideal she thought I had...

          ...well then, I'm pissed. I'm damn pissed.

          And try as I might over the years, during the situations she walked bare-faced into that caused her pain which I saw coming but knew she'd never accept my guidance to get her out of the way of, I was never able to get angry, to shake her by the shoulders and say LOOK. I was always the one that had to be shown.

          If NOTHING else, that's not me, not anymore.
          • Re: Our Brightness

            Fri, February 8, 2008 - 7:38 PM
            She may be quick on the draw, but there's such a things as emotional and relational inteligence. Could be that she's still learning in these areas?

            Hey, off topic and subject change and all, but howzabout sharing some cool things about yourself?
            • Re: Our Brightness

              Mon, February 11, 2008 - 8:58 AM
              >Hey, off topic and subject change and all, but howzabout sharing some cool things about yourself?

              Heh, sure. It's barely important to be anonymous anymore, as everyone knows now that I was really concerned about finding out by stumbling on it.

              I'm 32, I'm at the moment completely stoked about the beginning of my surfing season starting soon. I surf San O primarily, trail six, the nude beach. My wife got me into it, believe it or not. Liberated as I am I just never thought to put myself on a nine foot stick all blowin in tha wind, but it got to feel so freeing board-shorts are itchy now. ;)

              My wife, ex runway model, waterski-team champion, basically the end-all be-all of trophy wives except for the fact that she's unbelievably tender, mind-numbingly loving, and capeable of doing the near impossible of putting up with me for more than a few hours at a time.

              DJ since 97, started in strip clubs because where I'm from that's the only place you get to *start* djing. Moved on to Gothic/Industrial clubs when I could leave my sleepy lil town and got into fetish performance.

              Got a lil overwhelmed by the drug-part of the lifestyle in 2000 and by 01 was pretty much a wreck. String of abusive relationships I kept trying entirely too hard at, Moved around alot and DJed where I could, did a little booking, lived a little, and that pretty much brings us up to date.

              I hope I've covered enough "cool things" ;) But that's me in a nutshell... heh.
    • Re: Our Brightness

      Wed, February 6, 2008 - 11:22 AM
      Oh, and my nick wasn't as well thought out as all that. lol

      "The Diary of Jane" is a Breaking Benjamin song. Overplayed or no it could be a poem about how I felt yesterday.

      Hence... Breaking Benjamin = Broke Ben :)
  • Re: The Diary of Jane

    Fri, February 8, 2008 - 3:46 PM
    Hokay folks!

    I am wordlessly grateful for all your input, but after the loooooooooong correspondance between Jane and I, I'm in the best mood I've been in a long, long time. What's going to happen to our freindship? Well, maybe I'll keep this acct active and come back and tell you, but I've found a new role to play, and a truely equal and honest friendship is what I'll have, or none at all. (Wow.... WOW, still sucks, I mean sucks to say, but there it is.)

    Jane is a great girl. She's engaged, I was one of the first they told! There was even a point they asked me to give her away. I found that hilariously apt. The joke has soured somewhat since ;) Her boy, he's bright, I can see it. He's got one of those expressions where you think of that crazy technicolor soul swirling around right under his skin. HE is definately what Jane deserves in a man, a husband, a lover. I am expressly and singularly proud of Jane and all she achieved.

    But that doesn't excuse treating a grown-ass-man with kid gloves. A best friend should know better.

    So think fondly on Jane please? Think kindly on me too. I'm no stalker, no hanger-on for the sake of vulnerability later. I'm just a boy who was a little confused about where I stood, and the one hand that shoulda steadied me packs a hell of a whallop when it's toting a baseball bat.

    But it's okay, I got a thick skull.

    Just ask my wife. ;)

Recent topics in "Love Without Labels"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Braving the label 2 June 29, 2008
who are we? solar 95 June 27, 2008
LOOKING Jack 1 May 11, 2008
Bi Nature: Party in the East Bay for Bi Couples and Single Bi... offlineEl Indio 0 May 10, 2008